
Barn Conversion or New Build in Rural North Devon: What Landowners Should Consider
For landowners who are considering the development potential of their property in the North Devon countryside, an existing barn can present as an exciting opportunity. Before deciding how best to proceed however, it is important to understand the options available and the potential of both the building and the wider site.
Barn conversions are a common approach taken to create unique homes in the countryside, particularly in North Devon where agricultural buildings are a key part of the landscape. On the other hand, a new build home can provide greater freedom to respond to the client's requirements and the site's setting.
But which option is better?
There is no universal answer to this question. However, before deciding between conversion and new build, there are a number of factors to consider.
Begin With What You Already Have
An existing barn or building is typically very helpful, but its presence alone does not necessarily mean that conversion is the most viable option.
One of the first things that must be considered is the existing structure itself. What condition is it in? Is it redundant or in use? What has it historically be used for? Is it capable of being retained?
Traditional barns and agricultural buildings can offer character and generous internal space, as well as opportunities to work with existing stone and other materials. However, they can also come with their own challenges.
The main question to ask is not simply 'Can I fit a house in it?' It is whether the existing building can provide a suitable foundation for creating a home.
What Does Planning Allow?
Planning is likely to be the most significant consideration when comparing the 2 options.
1) For Conversion:
There are various options when converting an existing barn. For the conversion of an agricultural building, a common approach to residential use is through Class Q Permitted Development, which allows certain agricultural buildings to be converted into 1 or more residential dwellings without the need for full consent, as long as specific criteria is met.
We have gone into further detail about Class Q Permitted Development in a previous article on our website, which you can read here.
Alternatively, other common approaches to barn conversions and rural 'reuse' in North Devon include 3 development management policies known as:
- DM27 (Reuse of Disused and Redundant Rural Buildings)
- DM25 (Residential Extensions and Domestic Development)
- DM18 (Tourism Accommodation)
We also dive into more detail on this in a separate article, which can be read by clicking here.
2) For New Build:
A new build presents a different planning challenge.
In North Devon, the location of the site is very important. Local planning policies generally seek to direct housing towards existing towns and recognised settlements, as supposed to in the countryside; however, that does not mean obtaining permission for a rural new build is impossible, there just needs to be a solid planning basis for the proposal.
The main question to ask is 'Is the principle of a new dwelling acceptable here?'
One circumstance where a new build may be allowed is where there is an essential need for a rural worker to live at or near their place of work. For farms or other rural enterprises, a new dwelling could be justified by an essential operations need; evidence would be required to demonstrate why a worker needs to live at/near the place of work, and why this cannot be met by existing accommodation.
A stronger position for a new build would be through a Fallback planning position; this process enables you to build upon an existing permitted development right (such as Class Q consent) as it already establishes a form of development on site. Through the Fallback route, you can apply to demolish the original design consented through the permitted development, and rebuild a new dwelling.
More details on Fallback planning can be read in a separate WSCA article here.
Conversion Does Not Always Equal Cheaper
It is easy to assume that because there is an existing structure, converting will automatically cost less than building from scratch. However, that is not necessarily true.
Existing rural buildings can provide opportunity, but they also bring uncertainty and, more importantly, can unveil hidden costs. Despite already being in situ, it is common for these existing buildings to require structural repairs, as well as floor and roof upgrades or replacements. There may also be challenges with moisture problems, insulation, drainage, airtightness, and the existing materials, which may require substantial improvements to meet current standards.
Alternatively, with a new build there is greater control over construction from the start. It can be designed to meet current requirements as well as your own needs and requirements, rather than having to adapt to an existing building to meet them.
Therefore, when weighing up the options, it is important that the comparison should be made on the basis of the whole project, rather than assuming that retaining an existing structure will save money.
VAT should also be considered; how VAT applies will most likely differ between barn conversions and new builds. Constructing new dwellings generally means there is no VAT on build costs. On the other hand, if you are converting an agricultural barn to residential use, VAT on build costs apply but are reduced from 20% to 5%.
Existing Character VS Design Freedom
A fundamental difference between conversion and new build is the starting point of the design.
With a conversion, the existing building will lead the design; it's structure, materials, openings and character will all influence how it can successfully be adapted. Crucially, external changes should be minimal and respect the original form.
On the other hand, a new build offers a different opportunity. The orientation, materials, internal arrangement and relationship with the landscape can all be considered from the beginning, allowing more flexibility and freedom over how you choose to design it.
Neither approach is inherently better; they simply both offer different opportunities.
Looking Beyond The Building
Whether converting an existing barn or creating a new build dwelling, the building itself is only part of the picture.
There are many contributing influences that may affect what is achievable for both options, including access, drainage, utilities, ecology, ground conditions, flood risk and the wider landscape.
Questions around the relationship between the development and its surroundings also should be asked: How prominent will the development be within the landscape? Where will vehicles park? Are new roads or significant external works required?
These considerations should form part of the early assessment of the site due to their implications on feasibility, planning and cost.
Finding the Right Approach for Your Site
There is no single answer as to whether converting an existing building or pursuing a new build is the best option. Every site is different!
Converting a barn/agricultural building can give a redundant building a new purpose and create a home with a strong connection to the history of its setting. A new build, where planning policy permits it, can offer greater flexibility, as well as more freedom to meet the needs of its occupants, and modern expectations for design.
The key is to understand the potential of both the building and the wider site before anything else.
Sometimes the opportunity is in the building you already have. Sometimes it is in the land around it. Understanding the difference is where a successful project begins.
How We Can Help
An early conversation can help establish what may be achievable before significant time and money is committed to a particular approach.
At Woodward Smith Chartered Architects, we can help assess both the existing building and the wider site to establish what opportunities may be worth exploring. This can include reviewing the planning context and history of the site, considering what potential there is for conversion or new development, identifying any key constraints, and advising the most appropriate route forward.
Where a project has potential, we can guide it through the next stages, from feasibility and concept designs to planning, Building Regulations and construction.
If you own a barn, agricultural building or rural land in North Devon or the wider South West, and would like to explore its potential, get in touch with our team today to arrange an initial discussion free of charge.
Get In Touch

Contact Us
Woodward Smith Chartered Architects
6 Tuly Street
Barnstaple
Devon
United Kingdom
EX31 1DH